Will Democrats Finally Take the Courts Seriously?

Posted by

In March, as part of myself and Jill’s project to help get out the vote in 2020, I warned about impending doom as it pertains to the courts in America. I highly recommend you read that particular post because it lays out all of the issues we’ll be facing in the coming months. Decisions await in many areas of concern, including the viability of the Affordable Care Act, Roe V Wade, and climate change.

Unfortunately, now we must deal with something I was hoping would not come to fruition. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the Notorious RBG as she came to be known, passed away almost two weeks ago, after a long and gallant fight with pancreatic cancer.

Our worst nightmare is now upon us. The current president is again upending the norms and precedents exhibited by previous presidents by nominating Court of Appeals Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court. If confirmed, she will replace one of the most legendary and magnificent legal minds we’ve ever seen – not even five weeks before the American people are about to make their choice for president.

The hypocrisy from the Republican party knows no bounds. I’m not even going to go there.

As I warned in my March post, we’re now looking at a 6-3 majority for the conservatives. While I based my admonition on a possible Trump victory, there was always the chance RBG wouldn’t make it until a Democrat, now Joe Biden assumed the inauguration stage on January 20, 2021. Now, it’s not going to matter one way or the other. Amy Coney Barrett is going to be the next Supreme Court Justice. There’s not much the Democrats can do to stop it.

Yes, Democrats are pissed, and rightly so. Some call for Biden to “pack the courts,” were he to win, a reference to adding several justices to even out the Court’s ideological tilt to the far-right. While it’s constitutionally possible to do it, I wouldn’t hold my breath that Biden would do such a thing. But he has to win first to even think about such a drastic change. We shall see.

The fact that Mrs. Barrett, considered a far-right conservative with questionable views on women’s rights, health care, and other lightning rod issues, is replacing the liberal RBG makes it that much harder to swallow. But the current president wants his pick because he thinks she might help him when (not if) he challenges the results of the election. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is more than happy to oblige him.

I’ve written before about the disastrous McConnell. He’s as much a danger to this country as the current president. And it makes the upcoming election even more crucial that we remove this man from his perch atop the power totem pole of the United States Senate. He’s most likely going to win a seventh term in his home state of Kentucky, and that’s depressing enough. But if we do what we have to do in November, we can render him virtually powerless going forward.

What are some of the future scenarios, and what must we do to stop the bleeding?

First, what we need to do is make sure Joe Biden is the next president of the United States. Looking at the Court’s current makeup of the three justices left on the liberal side, Stephen J. Breyer is 82 years-old. There’s a reasonably high probability that he’s not going to stick around very much longer. If Biden is elected and Breyer decides to retire, he can replace him with someone similar ideologically.

If the current president wins, can we realistically expect Breyer to last another four years on the Court? I’d certainly not count on it. To even keep the Court where it is right now – 6-3, Biden must prevail on November 3. Otherwise, we seriously might be looking at a 7-2 conservative majority. If that doesn’t motivate you to vote, nothing will.

So a Biden victory would not only help us keep the current makeup, at least ideologically, the same, we’d also have a chance, albeit a slim one, to replace a conservative justice in Biden’s first term. Justice Clarence Thomas is 72 years old, and Samuel Alito is 70 – certainly not aged, especially when it comes to long tenures by judges. Nevertheless, you never know what health issues may arise, or maybe even a desire to move on to private life. The latter is highly unlikely, but still possible.

In my unlikely scenario, we’d be able to move the Court back to a 5-4 conservative majority, with Justice John Roberts remaining the sometimes wild card on various decisions. I’m trying my best to be optimistic here, folks. It’s not easy!

Either way you look at it, the Democratic Party, especially in recent years, has never taken the courts as seriously as their Republican counterparts. And it’s not hard to see why. The Republican Party has drifted so far to the right, their message to the voters seems to be: “We aren’t changing, so we’ll use the power we have to stiff-arm the courts to our will. And the Democrats can go to hell. Our ideas suck, but we’ll force you to heel to our whims by controlling the courts for decades to come.”

I hate to put it those terms, but that’s what we’re facing. As I mentioned in my March post, it’s not just the Supreme Court; it’s the rest of the federal courts as well. The current president gets the approved judge list from The Federalist Society, nominates them, and hands it over to Mitch McConnell, who moves lightning fast to assure their confirmation in the Republican-controlled Senate.

Funny, it’s the only thing he moves fast on these days.

Again, most of these judges are far-right, young, and unqualified – failing even to receive the stamp of approval from the American Bar Association. The Republicans have carved quite the niche for themselves and their extremist base and corporate masters. The only thing we can do now is to stop the bleeding.

So beyond all of us making sure that Joe Biden becomes the next president of the United States, we also need to make sure that the Senate flips to Democratic control. There are many more vulnerable Republican seats than Democratic ones this year. Electing Biden and giving him a Democratically controlled Senate is equally essential.

The current president is likely in the process of losing this election and taking down the whole Republican Party with him if we are to believe recent polling. He’s fighting like hell to delegitimize this election, seemingly resigned to his fate – unless he sows doubt, tells baseless lies, and awaits his chance to challenge every vote he possibly can. Getting his third justice confirmed to the Court gives him a fighting chance, in his view.

My friends, the trifecta is within our reach – keep the House, win the White House, and flip the Senate. Let’s resign ourselves to the fact that he’ll get his latest pick through. But on November 3, we can stop McConnell’s power grab, we can help limit the damage to all of our federal courts, and we can set the stage for getting things done for the American people.

What we’ve seen over the last four years is nothing short of a radical right-wing coup, brought about by a pathologically lying criminal president who has no regard for the law or any precedent our democracy depends upon for survival.

The current president has reshaped the courts so that the evangelical community gives him a pass for all of his despicable and appalling behavior. It’s one of the most disgraceful alliances in political history.

But there’s more of us than there is of them. It’s a fact the current president knows all too well. It’s why he’s trying to steal the election, folks. He can’t win based on his pathetic record. But he thinks he can by utilizing his advantage at the Supreme Court.

I hope that Democrats will never take the makeup of the courts for granted again in the future. We’re paying dearly for this mistake as we speak. While we napped, the Republicans were wide awake, plotting and scheming their way to judicial dominance.

But for now, November 3, 2020, looms, lurking like a gigantic anvil hovering over democracy’s survival. Are we going to keep it hanging, or will we let it come crashing down, rendering America powerless to the wannabe dictator?

I can’t imagine the American people wanting another four years of this man. But I was surprised in 2016. Let’s don’t make the same mistake twice. We’ve got a chance to make a statement – a substantial one at that.

There’s only one solution to this madness: Landslide. Let’s do this!

Discord & Dissension Table of Contents

America’s Wake-up Call Table of Contents


  1. Yes! The trifecta and then get a liberal majority in the Court even if it means increasing the membership. The events of the last days may have stopped the attempt to push thru the new appointment until next year.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I hope it has stopped the appointment Dan. Or at the very least, delay it indefinitely. It’s an illegitimate pick, and the second one stolen by Moscow Mitch. Makes me very angry!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Landslide is the only hope. There are still far too many into the tens of millions who support Trump just because he does as they want him to.
    Not to vote out of some mis-guided naïve pseudo political stance is irresponsibility verging on the same criminality as drunk-driving.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Good to hear from you Roger! Yes, irresponsibility indeed. What I’d like to see is something along the lines of a 55% to 38% popular vote tally and of course an overwhelming electoral landslide victory. It’s the only way to shut them all up. Well, most of them that is!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. In that twisted way which is the sad reflection of the state the USA political divide it is as well he has survived his Covid episode. Otherwise there would be screams of ‘Assassination’, mobs out on the streets looking to vent their thuggishness and of course at least one unhinged person with a semi-automatic….No I am not exaggerating or being darkly comical

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Yes Roger, the political divide is about as bad as it’s ever been before. Maybe even worse than out turbulent 1960s. These next 4 weeks will be the launching pad for hundreds, if not thousands of books/novels. Unprecedented stuff!

        Liked by 1 person

      3. I suspect worse than the 60s, of course my perspectives and memories were coloured with teenage ‘tints’. As I recall the types who are now treated with respect by the Right were thought of a ‘kooks’ and a bit of an embarrassment to the GOP, in general.
        And consensus seemed to be hanging on in there.
        Trump would have been chewed up and spat out by the likes of LBJ & Nixon without them even pausing for breath

        Liked by 1 person

      4. Oh, no doubt about that Roger. And both of those two presidents certainly had their temperament issues. But nothing like HIM!!!

        Liked by 1 person

      5. Both those characters were political men, they knew the ups and the downs, they knew how to play by the rules and how to win folk of many kinds over. It’s true they were not nice guys and had a fine share of hypocrisies and prejudices as well as whole battalions of demons (both coming from political backwaters and not being ‘elite’).
        However they were not put there by one section of the population and then did as that section wanted them to. We can blame Trump for all manner of things, the truth is when you analyse it he is doing what his supporters are telling him to, he doesn’t have one constructive thought in his head, he is only concerned with the perks and can’t cope with the demands, as a political operators he is a light-weight, a shabby little banner for the far-right to wave, like I said ‘their very own little action toy’
        It is a very sad reflection on the state of the USA politics, although we in the UK are hardly shining examples of the correct way of doing things.

        Liked by 1 person

      6. I just do not know why, or how, supposedly educated societies could possibly elect buffoons like our current president. That’s a whole other subject though Roger. Do people in the UK consider Boris Johnson in that way? To me, he’s somewhat buffoonish, but appears to have a bit more intellect than Trump. Or, actually, a lot more intellect than Trump. Who doesn’t? LOL

        Liked by 1 person

      7. With regards to the last question I would venture to suggest a distressingly noticeable minority of his voter base, who also carry firearms.
        Johnson is also a symptom of the unhappy state of the political system of a nation. Yes he does have more of an intellect than Trump and I feel holds him in contempt. Johnson is a product of our class system, comes from what we would think of as the ‘upper crust’ who are not of the titled folk went to the right school and university and obtained a degree in Classics, floated into ‘journalism’ (of the frivolous type, floated about society, had a stint as Mayor of London.
        Then we come to the Brexit era and he finds himself in the Cabinet and in the total bankruptcy of our politics becomes leader of the Conservative Party and wins an election (Though this was with the help of the stunningly inept Labour Opposition led by the hopelessly inadequate to the task Jeremy Corbyn).
        You can see some parallels I am sure.
        I am something of a political orphan these days, my traditional home Labour, not just the leadership but a shrill group within the party betrayed the country by basically examining the world…how shall I put it through the exit tract of the digestive system.

        Liked by 1 person

      8. Thanks for that Roger. You’ve enlightened me a bit on Johnson for I did not know much about him. Yes, a parallel indeed with what’s happening over here. If the polls hold, and that’s a big IF as far as I’m concerned, Biden will beat the Mussolini wannabe. I’m very hopeful he will lead us out of the current mess we’re in. Stay tuned Roger….the roller coaster ride of American politics is about to get very adventurous!!

        Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s