When Winning Is Losing: Evangelicals’ Pugnacious Pursuits

Posted by

Even during the time of my greatest evangelical fervency, I was not a fan of evangelicals’ much-revered John MacArthur, the pastor of the gigantic Grace Community Church in California. I was and still am, however, in the minority in that view. MacArthur is one of the most influential leaders in the evangelical movement. So, when he openly defies legally imposed state health sanctions on corporate gatherings, he sets a trend many other evangelical churches are likely to follow. And when he parrots our patently partisan president in falsely proclaiming children to be essentially immune to the COVID-19 virus, evangelicals throughout the nation take his words as gospel. When he cites the need to gather those children by the hundreds for Bible lessons as justification for mass gatherings, he sets an evangelical standard sure to be emulated.

MacArthur better be sure he’s right; his own very rigid theology condemns to eternal hell-fires anyone who fails to precisely obey God’s laws. If his defiance of state regulations violates the Romans 13 passage about obeying governmental authorities he and most other evangelicals apply so commonly yet selectively, then this leader of a most graceless Grace Community Church will forever be crying out for mercy as he burns in eternal agony.

MacArthur’s Creed

John MacArthur is probably the highest profile purveyor of an evangelical doctrine often referred to as “Lordship Salvation.” This creed holds that in order to be “saved” from an eternity of burning in the fires of hell—never being able to die—one must believe in the atonement provided through the death of Jesus the Messiah (Christ) AND live a godly life. Throughout one’s life, one must work diligently at avoiding sin in order to escape eternal damnation.

If you couple that doctrine with the plentiful prospects for falling to such temptations, one should wonder why anyone—much less the thousands of faithful congregants—would voluntarily pass through the doors of the inappropriately-named Grace Community Church (GCC). It would seem that the only way for GCC congregants to avoid despair and embrace hope would be to take a colossal existential leap—a leap necessitated because of the obvious lack of the attribute the church is named for.

Lives at Stake

Meanwhile, this very strict and authoritarian church leader defies state health authorities’ call for strict guidelines as a means of mitigating the spread of a virus that has killed more than 170,000 Americans and nearly three-quarters of a million humans around the planet. His justification for this civil disobedience is that “We must obey God rather than men,” which was the first-century apostles’ answer when government authorities told them to quit preaching.

MacArthur’s answer might sound biblically appropriate—initially. But look a little deeper and see this distinction: When the high priest and the ruling council forbade the apostles’ preaching, it was a comprehensive demand. No preaching anywhere in the city, under any circumstances. California’s COVID-based health regulations pertaining to this situation are not absolute, nor are they aimed specifically at preaching the gospel.

The regulations state as follows:

  • All gatherings should be postponed or canceled. 
  • This includes gatherings such as concerts, conferences, and professional, college, and school sporting events. 
  • Gyms, health clubs, and theaters should be closed. 
  • A “gathering” is any event or convening that brings together people in a single room or single space at the same time, such as an auditorium, stadium, arena, large conference room, meeting hall, cafeteria, or any other indoor or outdoor space.

The regulations do not ban religious gatherings in particular; rather, they ban large, indoor gatherings of any kind. Religious groups–wearing masks and following social-distancing guidelines–may gather in smaller assemblies and preach as they choose. Churches were not specifically targeted. No one within California’s government has called for a ban on preaching the Christian gospel. So MacArthur’s citation of the first-century apostles’ declaration about obeying God over men is, like the name of his church, inappropriate and misleading. Sadly, evangelicals throughout the nation will view this flawed analysis from one of their revered leaders as the final word.

Deference Defeats Defiance

The very Bible evangelicals uphold as their ultimate guide for beliefs and behaviors plainly declares that governments serve a purpose. The passage evangelicals regularly refer to as justification for supporting their ungodly choice as our current president, Romans 13:1, says, “Let everyone be subject to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God.” But that subjection has become very selective for evangelicals; it applies when attempting to cajole others into supporting their ungodly president, but it has no bearing on decisions that counter their preferences.

A favorite-but-often-misunderstood (and rarely applied) Bible passage among evangelicals is Philippians 2:3-8, which says,

Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves, not looking to your own interests but each of you to the interests of the others. In your relationships with one another, have the same mindset as Christ Jesus: Who, being in very nature God, did not consider equality with God something to be used to his own advantage; rather, he made himself nothing by taking the very nature of a servant, being made in human likeness. And being found in appearance as a man, he humbled himself by becoming obedient to death— even death on a cross!

A Gospel of Humility

Pastor John MacArthur—and many or most other evangelical pastors and congregants—seem to have forgotten the key gospel message of humility. Most modern evangelicals—like their new messiah in the White House—are more concerned with “winning” than with following the true Messiah who valued others above Himself, who looked to the interest of others, who took on the nature of a servant. They’ve put their desires for grand gatherings ahead of the public health, ahead of the interest of others.

MacArthur and likeminded evangelicals might win their lawsuit against the State of California, County of Los Angeles, and retain their right to gather indoors by the thousands with no masks and no social distancing, but as they infect one another and then spread those infections to thousands of others, they will have lost their souls, their humanity, their opportunity to be like the one they pretend to follow.


  1. I hadn’t heard of this John MacArthur until today, but I must say I’m not impressed by a man who would put thousands of lives at risk needlessly … for any reason. And in truth, if you peel back the layers of b.s., I suspect the main reason is to collect all those lovely donations that probably help pay for MacArthur’s lifestyle. But, that’s only the cynic in me. If it were not that these people will go forth and infect thousands of others, I would say let them congregate and infect each other … they are adults and responsible for their own actions, their own stupidity. But no, they will carry the virus home to their kids, their elderly parents, co-workers, friends, neighbors, and pretty soon there will be a surge in their city. Such stupidity this pandemic has brought out in people … such selfishness and arrogance. Sigh.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. By evangelical mega-church and mega-ministry standards, MacArthur is a borderline pauper, with a net worth of just $14 million. Some have a net worth north of $100 million. Forget the Bible’s many admonitions about resisting the temptation to seek monetary wealth. Do as I say, not as I do.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Ahhhh … a pauper indeed! Can’t compare with ol’ Joel Osteen!!! Yes, it seems to me there is a large portion of those who would call themselves ‘Christian’ who have completely lost the message.


  2. McArthur is nothing more than a product of the thousands who came before him. He simply repeats what has been quoted ad nauseam for several hundreds of years. The teachings of Christ through the several gospel passages that talk of love and humility are foreign to him and to the many like him. It has become more important to “push Christianity” than to demonstrate the true message of their Leader.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. My only taste of Evangelicism came from a week i spent learning about Jim Baker’s video set up in both of his campuses. He and Tammy Faye were still riding high but the IRS was breathing down their necks. If i didn’t trust those two before I sure did after. And then after he got out of prison he continued his old crooked ways. He was selling some snake oil remedy to cure the Virus. At least he didn’t do it with his pants unzipped like Fawell Jr.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I am very well versed in evangelical process and learned by the time I could coherently discern fact from fiction that most of what was being spoon fed to me in church was complete hypocricy. By the time I was a young adult I was convinced that the rivers of fire and brimstone of hell would be lined with God’s faithful who picked and chose what scripture applied to their particular agenda. I call the Christian view of God’s love the Great Bait and Switch of religion. As small children we are enveloped in the vision of Jesus and God as unconditionally loving entities whom we can never disappoint or lose Favor with; but by the time we are teens, Sunday school lessons point to a judgmental God, one that is waiting for us to slip up and sin, for which we have to beg forgiveness before we can once again bask in that love. Why do Evangelicals like Trump? They are all entertainers, snake oil salesmen and Charlatans who depend on the need of people to not have to think for themselves or accept responsibility for their actions. Seeking a Savior so they don’t have to be accountable and demonizing things they don’t wish to understand. Is my cynicism showing? Sorry. 😔.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s