Beware, Evangelicals, of Self-Fulfilling Prophecy

Posted by

“Christian persecution IS coming to the United States.” So says the evangelical website Truth and Fire. It’s a common theme in evangelical circles. As an evangelical for nearly five decades, my response to such claims is that if Christian persecution does come to the United States, white evangelical Americans will be largely to blame. Beware, evangelicals, of self-fulfilling prophecy.

This “sky is falling” doom-and-gloom, expect-persecution mentality is, as I mentioned above, a common refrain in evangelical churches throughout the nation; I heard it often—and at times repeated it. Yes, the Bible does tell Christ followers to expect persecution, but it does not suggest that believers should go out of their way to unearth it or to invite it. But that tendency to proclaim discrimination—even when it’s only perceived—has an ironic allure to the faithful. Victimhood can be brandished as proof of one’s devotion to the faith.

Indifference, Not Persecution

What America’s white evangelicals typically fail to understand is the difference between persecution and indifference. Evangelicals tend to have an inflated view of our significance. The 75 percent of Americans who are not evangelical are not focused on oppressing the 25 percent who are evangelicals. The simpler and more uninspiring truth is that non-evangelicals rarely even think about evangelicals.

Yet when the nation faces a key cultural shift, many evangelicals tend to see that turn as being aimed squarely at us and our belief system. The victim mentality then kicks in, leading to defensiveness and hostility. Meanwhile, those advocating for the change—whatever it might be—are unlikely to have given any consideration to evangelicals or the Bible; they’re simply advocating for what they see as a cultural course correction.

Granted, some of those “course corrections” do run counter to biblical mandates and to long-held evangelical ideals, but riling religious conservatives is rarely the motive behind progressives’ policy pursuits. Evangelicals would do well to stop, count to ten, and consider the motivations of our perceived enemies before proclaiming ourselves victims of liberal oppression. Rather than being defensive, evangelicals could choose to view such incidents through a different lens.

A Different Perspective

Take, for example, the case of the Colorado baker who refused to bake a wedding cake for a gay couple. Yes, the couple could have taken their business elsewhere. But, likewise, the baker could have taken a different course of action. Why not, rather than refuse them service, use the occasion as an opportunity to befriend the couple? Why not, over the course of that friendship, help the couple to experience God’s grace? Why exclude when we can include? I’m sure that had Jesus been a baker rather than a carpenter, He would have baked the cake and befriended the couple, much like He befriended the “sinful” Samaritan woman at the well. (Remember, we’re all sinners.)

But all too often, evangelicals’ victim mentality makes many among us suspicious, cynical, and reactionary rather than inclusive and hospitable. And below, I believe, is the primary reason for evangelicals’ misunderstandings and wayward responses.

The Paradox of Evangelical Redemption

Evangelicals happily point to biblical passages that proclaim salvation by faith through God’s grace. The “born again” experience is as simple as the verse commonly waved before the cameras at sports events, John 3:16, which says, “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.” Eternal life in a place free of pain and suffering granted for simply believing is too great an offer for many to reject. And that simple message tends to attract simple people. That’s not to say that all evangelical Christians are simpletons. Counted among our ranks are notables such as Isaac Newton, Blaise Pascal, C.S. Lewis, and Francis Schaeffer, to name just a few.

But the majority of self-proclaimed evangelicals are simple, hard-working folks who responded to an offer that was too good to pass up, but who, following that acceptance, found the Bible too complicated to understand on their own. Evangelical leaders often encourage their flock to study the Bible for themselves, but the common reality is that most either make no such effort or, if they do, soon give up in frustration. Most who continue in the faith get their “spiritual sustenance” in a regurgitated form from their leaders. 

So if those leaders warn them of Christians being persecuted, they see no reason to doubt those warnings—especially if they feel that life has not treated them fairly. Suddenly, their difficult situation makes sense: Their struggles can be traced to persecution rather than to mistakes or bad choices they might have made throughout their lives. It’s always easier and more comforting to point the finger of blame at others than at ourselves. And that’s what evangelicals have been doing too commonly for far too long. We evangelicals need to learn and remember this: When looking for faults, first look in the mirror.  

Eventually They Will Bite Back

I, for one, have never experienced any persecution because of my faith. The challenges I’ve faced throughout my 65 years can be traced either to the challenging world we live in or to my own bad choices. I’m confident that if most American evangelicals were to honestly reflect on their lives, they too would have to admit that they’d suffered no persecution for their beliefs. But, rather than enduring deep self-reflection, it’s much easier to bark along in response to demagogues’ dog whistles hyping a narrative of liberal boogeymen out to get them. And that barking too often escalates to biting. We in the minority can bite only so long before those in the majority bite back.

If and when persecution of evangelicals does begin in America, evangelicals will have ourselves to blame.


  1. A well-reasoned and thoughtful analysis, which I hope will be taken in that spirit by your fellow evangelicals.

    I’m not one of them, but I was a practicing Catholic for over 50 years, and I’ve experienced the indoctrination that makes virtual automatons of adherents, for whom docile obedience and acceptance of what they’re told trump critical thinking.

    And speaking of “trump,” a recent letter to the editor in the local newspaper praised the President for all he does for evangelicals. I was tempted to respond that if the writer thinks Trump does it because he supports evangelicals, it’s the other way around — he does it because THEY support him and he needs their support to keep him in power. But I didn’t respond, because they’re incapable of seeing that everything he does, he does for his own self-interest….if he thought that NOT supporting evangelicals would get him re-elected, he would stop (his support) on a dime.

    Sorry if I got too political at the end, but it’s part of showing evangelicals’ mindset, and it’s all of a piece.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. No, I don’t think you were too political. I think your analysis was spot on. I’ve always argued that Trump has no principles or ideologies apart from advancing his own interests. I absolutely agree that “he does it because THEY support him and he needs their support to keep him in power.” I’ve argued with my siblings over that very thought. They gush over all the great things he’s done for Christians. My counterargument has always been that he supports evangelical causes because he is pandering to his base. So I also agree with you that “if he thought that NOT supporting evangelicals would get him re-elected, he would stop (his support) on a dime.” I’ve argued with my fellow evangelicals since the 2016 primaries that they were selling out all their principles in exchange for promises of policies they favor. Shortsightedness and thirst for power have become key characteristics of Republicans, which is why I left the GOP.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Thanks. BTW, I want to apologize for saying “it’s part of evangelicals’ mindset” as if ALL evangelicals don’t think for themselves. You are obviously an evangelical who does, and I’m sure there are others who do also.

        Liked by 2 people

  2. Good summation, Jerry. I think mistermuse pretty much said it all. I’ve always tried to be very respectful of people and their religion, as long as they don’t try to impose their beliefs on me. I largely shy away from discussions on religion simply to ensure that I don’t step on any toes. But, today’s evangelicals are testing the limits, and not only for me. Thanks for your thoughtful analysis.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Jill, I’m not ready to jettison my evangelical beliefs, but I have left the evangelical movement–along with the Republican Party. The marriage of those two entities, I’ve now come to believe, was by no means made in heaven. Their intimate alliance will be the downfall of both. That was a long, hard lesson for me to learn. Evangelicals need to quit being so political and pugnacious and start being more open-minded and gracious. Sadly, I don’t see that happening any time soon.

      Liked by 2 people

      1. No, nor would I ever suggest that. I am a firm believer in “Live and let live”, and I understand that we all believe something a bit different. But, I’m in complete agreement that the evangelicals have brought politics into their religion, and despite the constitutional mandate for separation of church and state, are attempting to bring their religion into our government, and it’s a recipe for disaster. I don’t see it happening soon, but … if we don’t heal the great divide in this nation soon, if we don’t set aside our differences and learn to live in peace, to accept each person for what they are, then I firmly believe the human species is on a path to self-extinction. Sadly, we will take most other life forms with us and it will be millions of years before the planet is once again teeming with life of any form. Sorry … I’ll just step down off of my soapbox now. 😉

        Liked by 2 people

      2. Excellent work Jerry. I respect the thoughtfulness of your reasoning. You’re able to look at things in a nuanced way, which is not something the current makeup of the Republican Party is capable of. Everything isn’t black and white. Everything isn’t written in stone. I appreciate the fact you understand that.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. It is my hope to couple Christianity with Counseling because most of my clients want nothing to do with God because of Scripture being used as a weapon in their formative years. I myself, am a recovering Catholic and once became saved took to my Bible because all churches fell short on delivering a positive interpretation of it. I agree that many have formed their own doctrines and few know how to press in with the written word.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s